What Does It Feel Like to Have Egg On Your Face?

For ninety years, awards season ran on a simple, glorious idea: Best Actor and Best Actress. Two races, two sets of winners, twice the argument and twice the fun.

Then the Gothams did away with it in 2021, and the Spirit Awards and LAFCA followed in 2022. Their reasoning was that if men and women are equal behind the camera, they must be interchangeable in front of it. So now there’s one category with ten nominees and half the winners.

They forgot that a performance by a woman and a performance by a man are not the same thing. We don’t watch them the same way and we don’t feel them the same way. Hepburn and Bogart weren’t up for the same prize because they weren’t doing the same job.

The results haven’t evened out. They swing back and forth: one year women sweep, the next year they’re shut out, depending on the group and the jury. A performance that would have won Best Actor or Best Actress now goes home with nothing. It also loses the early win that would have carried it into BAFTA, the Actor Awards, the Globes and the Oscars.

Meanwhile, the Academy, the Actor Awards, BAFTA, the NYFCC, the NSFC, the Globes and the Critics’ Choice Awards kept the split. They look smarter every January.

So, Gothams, Spirits, LAFCA: years later, what does it feel like?

Popular Articles

TheBrownees Rank the 145 Greatest Horror Movies, 1920 to 2026.

TheBrownees Rank the 145 Greatest Horror Movies, 1920 to 2026.

Spanning over a century of filmmaking, and tracing the gamut from slasher to psychological to supernatural, TheBrownees ranks the 135 greatest horror movies from 1920 to 2026. The top 15 are: Psycho, Midsommar, The Exorcist, The Shining, Alien, The Road, Dead Ringers, Take Shelter, Under the Skin, Carrie, Halloween, Rosemary’s Baby, The Substance, Hereditary and Don’t Look Now. Directors Tod Browning, Robert Eggers, Roman Polanski, George A. Romero and James Whale are each listed three times. Fourteen directors are represented twice – Ari Aster, John Carpenter, Wes Craven, Zach Cregger, David Cronenberg, Brian De Palma, Coralie Fargeat, Alfred Hitchcock, Tobe Hooper, Jordan Peel, Ken Russell, Steven Spielberg, Jacques Tourneur and Robert Wise. Fargeat, is one of five female directors on the list and the only one to be represented twice. The others are fellow French director Julia Ducoumau, British director Rose Glass and American filmmakers Kathryn Bigelow and Karyn Kusama. Be afraid! Be very afraid!

Subscribe for the latest reviews right in your inbox!