Diary of a Mad Housewife (1970) Queer Film. Eleanor Perry. A+

Carrie Snodgress
DIRECTOR: Frank Perry
Between 1968 and 1970, Frank Perry directed three great movies, each emblematic of its time and place. All three started life as adapted screenplays that captured the spirit of their source material with extraordinary economy and grace. The three films are: “The Swimmer” from 1968, based on the 1964 short story (in the New Yorker) by John Cheever, “Last Summer” from 1969, based on the 1968 novel by Evan Hunter and “Diary of a Mad Housewife” from 1970, based on the 1967 novel by Sue Kaufman. All three screenplays were written by Perry’s then-wife, Eleanor Perry, one of the great screenwriters. These movies were made on the East Coast, outside the Hollywood system, and were highly influential, if not essential, in establishing the American Independent Film as we know it today.
Their final collaboration, Diary of a Mad Housewife,  a razor-sharp portrait of upper-middle-class suffocation, is also their finest.  Carrie Snodgress is magnificent as Tina Balser, a woman who receives no respect from anyone in her life, least of all her petulant, status‑obsessed husband (Richard Benjamin, then at the height of his acting career) or her equally self‑absorbed lover (Frank Langella, making a striking film debut).
The film’s one sour note—very much a product of its era—is the revelation that Langella’s character is gay, a lazy narrative device meant to “explain” his cruelty and emotional sadism toward Tina.
Snodgress is breathtaking, delivering a performance of such wounded intelligence and quiet fury that she should have walked away with the Oscar for Best Actress.  Instead, she lost to Glenda Jackson in Women in Love (see above).
Adding to the film’s countercultural texture is a cameo by Alice Cooper and his band, who appear during a raucous party sequence performing “Ride with Me, Baby.”
Carrie Snodgress (1945–2004) has one of the more extraordinary and bittersweet stories in Hollywood history. In 1970, she was on the verge of becoming a major film star. Singer Neil Young saw her photograph and became fascinated with her. Snodgress later recalled that she barely knew who he was. Nevertheless, when they met, she fell immediately and passionately in love. She left her seven-year Universal contract behind and moved to Young’s Broken Arrow Ranch in Northern California. Young’s relationship with her inspired several songs, particularly “A Man Needs a Maid” from Harvest (1972), which refers directly to falling in love with an actress.
Their son, Zeke Young, was born in September 1972 with cerebral palsy, generally described as relatively mild. Snodgress devoted much of her time to raising him, making her withdrawal from filmmaking considerably more prolonged. An extraordinary coincidence followed: Young’s second son, Ben, born in 1978 to his subsequent wife Pegi, also had cerebral palsy, but much more severely. Young and Pegi eventually established the Bridge School in 1986, serving children with significant physical disabilities and communication needs.
In 1976, Sylvester Stallone originally wanted to cast Carrie Snodgress as Adrian Pennino in Rocky. At that stage, Stallone envisaged Adrian and her brother Paulie as Irish-American, with Harvey Keitel considered for Paulie. According to Stallone, Snodgress rejected the role because the production offered too little money. Stallone wanted her so badly that he reportedly offered to supplement her salary from his own. She still declined. The role ultimately went to Talia Shire, who received an Academy Award nomination for Best Actress.  It is worth emphasizing that Snodgress was not simply unavailable because of motherhood. The accounts specifically identify the inadequate salary as the reason she declined.
Snodgress and Young separated around 1975, and she eventually resumed acting. Her first significant return to film was Brian De Palma’s The Fury. She subsequently appeared in Pale Rider (1985), Murphy’s Law (1986), and numerous television productions. But she never regained the extraordinary professional momentum she had enjoyed in 1970. She also experienced a traumatic relationship with composer Jack Nitzsche, who assaulted her in 1979 and subsequently pleaded guilty to threatening her. In 1983, Snodgress obtained a child-support agreement with Young, providing $10,000 monthly and funding toward a home for herself and Zeke.
In a 1986 interview, she explained that she had never considered herself primarily a career woman. Her ambitions were to do good work, fall in love, and build a fulfilling personal life.

She died on April 1, 2004, of heart failure while awaiting a liver transplant at UCLA. Zeke was at her bedside.

NOW STREAMING ON YOUTUBE

https://thebrownees.net/88-queer-films-made-under-the-hays-code-1934-1968/
https://thebrownees.net/112-queer-films-from-the-new-hollywood-1968-1980/
The Swimmer (1968) Eleanor Perry (B) – TheBrownees
Last Summer (1969) Eleanor Perry (A) – TheBrownees
Eleanor and Frank Perry – TheBrownees
Play It As It Lays: A Deep Dive into Trauma – TheBrownees
Goodbye Columbus (1969) Queer Film B- TheBrownees

Popular Articles

TheBrownees Rank the 145 Greatest Horror Movies, 1920 to 2026.

TheBrownees Rank the 145 Greatest Horror Movies, 1920 to 2026.

Spanning over a century of filmmaking, and tracing the gamut from slasher to psychological to supernatural, TheBrownees ranks the 135 greatest horror movies from 1920 to 2026. The top 15 are: Psycho, Midsommar, The Exorcist, The Shining, Alien, The Road, Dead Ringers, Take Shelter, Under the Skin, Carrie, Halloween, Rosemary’s Baby, The Substance, Hereditary and Don’t Look Now. Directors Tod Browning, Robert Eggers, Roman Polanski, George A. Romero and James Whale are each listed three times. Fourteen directors are represented twice – Ari Aster, John Carpenter, Wes Craven, Zach Cregger, David Cronenberg, Brian De Palma, Coralie Fargeat, Alfred Hitchcock, Tobe Hooper, Jordan Peel, Ken Russell, Steven Spielberg, Jacques Tourneur and Robert Wise. Fargeat, is one of five female directors on the list and the only one to be represented twice. The others are fellow French director Julia Ducoumau, British director Rose Glass and American filmmakers Kathryn Bigelow and Karyn Kusama. Be afraid! Be very afraid!

Subscribe for the latest reviews right in your inbox!